What Flavor of Civil War?

"Civil war, such as you have just passed through naturally engenders feelings of animosity, hatred, and revenge. It is our duty to divest ourselves of all such feelings; and as far as it is in our power to do so, to cultivate friendly feelings towards those with whom we have so long contended, and heretofore so widely, but honestly, differed."
-Nathan Bedford Forrest
Sorry. I just like the irony of using a quote by Bedford Forrest as prologue to a ramble about civil wars, and in particular the one that seems headed down the tracks toward us right now.
Even with the startling outcome of the elections a couple weeks ago, my pessimisstic Irish heart leads me to doubt all will be well, that the kleptocracy in the White House will take its lumps and behave within the system.
But really, who believes that's going to happen? Congress will issue subpoenas, the executive branch will ignore them. Congress will take the next step under our rules, and sue in federal court to enforce the subpoena. The district judge will likely rule for Congress, and issue an order to show cause that will immediately be appealed. Finally, even this Supreme Court will have to admit the unitary executive has some constraints, and the subpoena will stand. Trump's people will ignore it.
And then . . . the U.S. Marshal's office will be tasked with enforcing the contempt citation that follows. They work for the DOJ, meaning Todd Blanche. These guys take the same oath as military officers to protect and defend the Constitution, so maybe some will try to do the right thing. Some will not. And although the rules, in an odd wrinkle, allow the district judge to appoint private citizens or local law enforcement to enforce its orders, you end up wih a scenario where guys with guns are on opposite sides of the crisis. We have a name for that.
Which leads me to the question of what our civil war will look like. Being Americans, and therefore focused mostly on our own history, we tend to view these conflicts through the lens of a regional conflict, pitting state against state, maybe blue against red. But the major cities in those red states are all pretty blue these days, while the countryside of very blue New York is crawling with MAGA types. So it's not just a matter of geography so much as urban against rural, new economy against old, more about class than regional loyalty.
That wasn't our War Between the States. It's also not the French Revolution, which only briefly pitted King versus the Estates General, with poor Louis trying to placate them by playing constitutional monarch and getting guillotined for his efforts.
No, I'm thinking instead of the English Civil War, of Roundheads versus Cavaliers. That one had a regional component, with the rural north and west predominantly Royalist and the urban and trade-based southeast (London being the center) siding with Parliament. The fight there was over their own version of the Unitary Executive, then called the Divine Right of Kings, as well as Charles wrecking the economy with taxes and trying to impose his own version of Christian Nationalism, in the form of force-feeding his population the Anglican host, on a fairly religiously diverse country.
We all know how that one ended. Or at least if you are a history major of a certain age, or maybe bumbled across Richard Burton as Cromwell and Sir Alec Guiness as Charles in that movie from sixty years ago, you know the story. Cromwell created the New Model Army, and proceeded to clobber the Royalists, who initially had the upper hand with their military training, arms, and money. They gave Charles a second chance, which he blew by trying to start the war over again, so Parliament took steps to make sure that didn't happen a third time.

Can anyone now relate to a society where you take your kids to see an execution by beheading? As I've said before, Hartley was right: "The past is a foreign country. They do things differently there."
Maybe we'll do better, but humanity never changes despite the fancy technology and every day being casual day now.
And my gloomy Irish soul also compels me to mention the postscript in my analogy, with Cromwell turning into a sadistic murderer in his own right, engaging in genocide against my ancestors (the English just can't help themselves when it comes to their wild cousins on the other side of the Irish Sea), dying abed only to have his body exhumed so they could behead his corpse and stick his noggin on a post atop Westminster Hall for 23 years, so despised was his memory by the people over whom he served as Lord Protector.
And so it goes.
Time to shower and start the trek back to New York and Peg.



Comments